Review: The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping

Director:  Francis Lawrence

Stars:  Joseph Zada, McKenna Grace, Jesse Plemons

Fighting inevitability is a big throughline in Sunrise on the Reaping, something rather ironic to be pushing against in the second prequel to a behemoth franchise the size of The Hunger Games. In truth it’s a battle fought and lost before this latest instalment has gotten very far, and what ultimately unfurls is one of the year’s most colourful blockbusters, but also one of the most listless, lifeless and frustrating. Series mainstay Francis Lawrence (who has shepherded every instalment since Catching Fire) returns yet again for Haymitch Abernathy’s origin story. But unless you’re a dyed in the wool fan of Suzanne Collins’ source material, this poorly paced episode will serve as little more than a head-scratching footnote. Casual viewers will be baffled into submission. One of the few positives is that Reaping reinvigorates the franchise’s early mean-spiritedness. It has its bite back. But the wound is also neutered by the amount of drivel acting as anti-venom.

Relative newcomer Joseph Zada steps into Woody Harrelson’s shoes-to-be as the young Haymitch, 24 years prior to the events of the first Hunger Games. An assistant bootlegger in the rural outskirt of Panem’s 12th District, his birthday falls on the annual ‘reaping’ in which the region’s youths are rounded up and lotteried for ‘tributes’ to take part in the state’s mandated battle royale. As it is the ceremony’s 50th anniversary – the second Quarter Quell – President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) and his administration have deemed that there ought to be twice the number of tributes; four from each district. Haymitch isn’t initially one of the unlucky candidates, but finds himself dragged into the mix when the process spirals out of control. Thus he is separated from both his family and his furtive love, Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak).

By the time Harrelson inhabits the role, Haymitch has become a disgraced drunkard, but Reaping is more liable to drive viewers to drink. The young stars are game enough (Zada is joined by 2010s horror mainstay McKenna Grace as spunky proto-Barbie Maysilee, Ben Wang as bookie’s kid Wyatt and Molly McCann as pint-sized Louella), but their characters are paper thin and their chemistry with one another non-existent. It helps them little that Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie’s script clangs repeatedly with howlers. As for the other 44 players? Like the beginning of a season of The Traitors there’s just too many of them to keep up with or care about.

Fairing little better are the star-powered adult players. Fiennes is borderline comatose, phoning-in Snow, while typically eccentric turns from the likes of Elle Fanning, Glenn Close and Maya Hawke feel like shadows of the series’ past glories. Close seems like she’s cosplaying Gladys from Weapons and is generally more horrifying than Amy Madigan’s ever been. Only Kieran Culkin seems to nominally understand the assignment as his younger iteration of catty TV host Caesar Flickerman. With nearly every scene resting on his shoulders, it is Zada who unfortunately underwhelms most often, someway hampered by the complete absence of dramatic tension over his character’s fate in the games.

Flickerman tries to drum into the young tributes the importance of “presentation… and a good narrative”, but Lawrence and his screenwriters fumble these core concepts at nearly every turn. By the time of the opening ceremony Reaping already has the mantel of the most ostentatious looking major release this side of Megalopolis… but that comparison probably wasn’t the intention. The Quarter Quell arena looks dazzling, evoking a kind of Lord of the Flies in Teletubbyland. But as quick carnage ensues, the deluge of CG slop turns it into a queasy and garish landscape in which any old thing… just… happens. This is partially my own fault for not revising, but every obstacle that Haymitch encounters arrives inexplicably, from electrified butterflies to rabid squirrels (possibly ferrets, the digital gloop and terrible lighting makes defining this incident particularly tricky). When Snow angrily (or almost angrily) commands that they “activate the volcano” it’s as arbitrary as anything else. Unintentionally, I’m sure, Reaping scans like something someone’s making up as they’re going along. In keeping, there’s also a bush filled with berries that can pinch you. Of course there is. The fatigue from this sets in swiftly. Act three had be pondering the plural of deus ex machina.

Underneath all of this the movie has something to say, albeit nothing new for this series. The capital’s propaganda machine is forcefully dragged through the mud, as well it should be, and of course it rings as pertinent to our era of celebrity politicians, dubiously edited news, reality TV, and so-on and so-forth. Like us, the people of Panem are hunkered down in the middle of an oppressive time period. Katniss’ coming is a quarter century away. Inevitably (that word again) Reaping reaches toward this future, mainly through the mouthpiece of Jesse Plemons’ Plutarch Heavensbee (and that’s some good casting). The optimism for a brighter future is heartening, especially against the movie’s cruel (but oddly dull) treatment of Haymitch and his fellows. But even this has to contest with audience-baiting fan service (the late, ultimately immaterial coda that features Jennifer Lawrence, Josh Hutcherson and the aforementioned Harrelson), making the effort feel curiously insincere.

The more fanciful elements of Hunger Games have previously passed muster as a campy counter to the grim totalitarianism, making for an awkward but just-about-balanced fantasia. The seesaw feels off this time. Nothing in Reaping seems thrilling because so much of it reads, simply, as nonsense. But maybe that’s a Me Problem. If I’m to watch young people getting slain in ridiculous, improbable ways, I think I’ll stick to slasher movies. Fulfilling his destiny as a doomed, tragic poster-boy-cum-patsy for the resistance, Haymitch beseeches his fellow tributes to “tear up their scripts”. Metatextually, this is probably the best advice in the movie.

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close